.png){kind=small}
Which plan type offers the best balance of cost, coverage, and flexibility for your business?
The Health Insurance Dilemma for Business Owners
As a self-employed professional, LLC owner, or small business employer, finding the right health insurance plan is a balancing act between cost, coverage, and flexibility. The wrong choice can lead to high out-of-pocket expenses or inadequate benefits, impacting both your bottom line and well-being.
Using real application data from 2025, this analysis compares different plan options for business owners, helping you make an informed decision based on your business structure.
Key Takeaways at a Glance
Self-employed individuals benefit most from ACA marketplace plans with subsidies.
LLCs with multiple members can explore group health plans or HRAs to cut costs.
Small business employers may save with ICHRAs or SHOP marketplace options.
Plan costs vary significantly by state and premium level.
Visual Breakdown: Monthly Costs by Plan Type
I’ll generate a bar chart comparing average monthly premiums for these different plan types.
This bar chart compares average monthly premiums across different plan types for business owners:
ACA Marketplace Plans (for self-employed individuals) tend to be the most affordable when subsidies are applied.
Group Plans (LLC) and ICHRAs cost more but provide greater flexibility for businesses with employees.
Medicaid or Catastrophic Plans offer the lowest costs but have strict eligibility requirements.
Plan Type Breakdown: What’s Best for Your Business?
1. Self-Employed (No Employees): ACA Marketplace Plans
✅ Best For: Freelancers, gig workers, and sole proprietors
✅ Key Advantage: Premium tax credits reduce costs significantly
✅ Challenges: Must estimate income carefully to maximize subsidies
💡 Pro Tip: Choose a Silver Plan if you qualify for cost-sharing reductions—it lowers deductibles and copays without increasing your premium.
2. LLC Owners (One or More Members): Group Plans & HRAs
✅ Best For: Business partners or LLC members sharing a plan
✅ Key Advantage: Can offer tax-deductible group insurance
✅ Challenges: Premiums are higher than individual marketplace plans
💡 Pro Tip: Consider a Qualified Small Employer HRA (QSEHRA)—it lets you reimburse health costs tax-free without offering a full plan.
3. Small Business Employers: ICHRA & SHOP Plans
✅ Best For: Small businesses with employees
✅ Key Advantage: Offers tax-free reimbursements or group coverage
✅ Challenges: Higher administrative complexity
💡 Pro Tip: ICHRAs allow employees to pick their own plan while still benefiting from employer reimbursements—a flexible alternative to traditional group insurance.
State-by-State Premium Variations
This state-by-state comparison shows the variation in ACA marketplace plan costs, which is critical for self-employed individuals and small business owners deciding where to purchase coverage.
Key insights:
Some states have lower ACA plan costs, making them better for self-employed individuals.
Others have higher premiums, which may make HRAs or employer-sponsored options more attractive.
Choosing the Best Plan for Your Business
Self-employed individuals should leverage ACA marketplace subsidies to minimize costs.
LLC owners benefit from group plans or HRAs to manage expenses.
Small business employers can use ICHRA or SHOP plans to balance cost and flexibility.
State differences matter—researching premiums before selecting a plan can save thousands per year.
Would you like customized cost projections based on your income, state, and business structure? Stay tuned for more Aromedy Insights reports! 🚀
Data Disclaimer
This report is based on anonymized data from 499 real health insurance applications collected in 2025. The information reflects self-reported applicant details and insurer-provided quotes at the time of application. While this dataset offers valuable insights into premium costs, subsidies, and affordability trends, it is not exhaustive and does not represent all available insurance plans or market conditions. The findings are intended for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial, legal, or policy advice.
Comments